

The White Makélélé
By: Inara | September 27th, 2007
Time for another player profile! This time I’ve selected Jeremy “La Toule” Toulalan because he’s currently one of the best OL players and also because I might be infatuated with him. But shhh, don’t tell anyone. It’s a secret.
The midfield is a team’s engine, so when Mahamadou Diarra decided to leave for Real Madrid in 2006, Lyon were left with a gaping hole to fill in the heart of their team. Diarra was an integral part of four of Lyon’s title winning teams, so many felt that Diarra’s departure would weaken Lyon considerably.
But just as Tiago softened Michael Essien’s departure, Toulalan’s arrival ensured the club lost only a little bit of its momentum when they lost Diarra. In fact, one could even say that Toulalan brought qualities to Lyon’s midfield that were not there before.
A product of Nantes’ youth academy, he comes from a place that also produced such midfield gems as Didier Deschamps, Marcel Desaily, Christian Karembeu, and - you guessed it - Claude Makelele.
Toulalan is a very elegant player, one that is unafraid to make challenges and strong tackles (he collects between 7-11 yellow cards per season, and gets suspended two or three times as well). He’ll remind you of a terrier, always nipping at a player’s heels. He’s also surprisingly fast for such a solid and husky player, and is always at ease on the ball and deceptive to markers. At Nantes, he played more offensively, but at Lyon, he’s taken a more defensive role and usually patrols Makelele-esque in front of the back four. He’s also been working hard on his long passes, which have improved considerably. Some of his passes this season have been absolute beauties.
The strange thing about Toulalan is that despite having a powerful shot, he’s only scored one goal in L1 ever (and one for the U21s). In almost every game, he comes close, but either it just goes wide or the goalkeeper makes the save of the century. The last time he scored was in 2004!

“Oops, didn’t mean to clip you, but you’re in my way.”
In fact, his strong and steady displays, his simple but effective distribution, and his exceptional positional sense for Lyon and for France have prompted comparisons to both Deschamps and Makelele. While the tendency of the French to name any burgeoning talent as the “the new _____” can get annoying after awhile, in Toulalan’s case, it’s rather apt. When asked about how he feels about being compared to Deschamps and Makelele, he said:
“That’s pleasing to hear and if I win half as much as Deschamps won in his career I’ll be doing well. I’ve got time on my side but I want to be playing regularly for France as soon as possible. All I can do is play well for Lyon and hope that the rewards follow.”
And there have been plenty of rewards.
Toulalan graduated from the youth ranks and debuted in 2001 for Nantes, the incumbent L1 title winners (the last club to win before Lyon took over). That year also saw him debut in the Champions League against Bayern Munich. He would remain with Nantes for five seasons, and while there, he would be voted France’s best young player in 2005.
Lyon had actually approached Nantes that spring with an offer close to €10m, but Nantes refused because they wanted to keep their best player. Unfortunately for them, the following year saw them close to debt, and they had no choice but to sell Toulalan, this time for €7.5m.

TOU-LA-LA!!!
Toulalan’s arrival confirmed Mahamadou Diarra’s departure, but the club was unconvinced that Toulalan would be enough. Despite his stellar displays with France’s U21 team (he was the captain and was named on UEFA’s Team of the Tournament), Lyon recruited another defensive midfielder, Alou Diarra.
Everyone thought that the new Diarra would be the starter - after all, he got to play in the World Cup final! But Toulalan slotted in immediately and seamlessly, and his impact was so positive that Diarra featured only sporadically throughout the season - a situation which led to several bust ups between Diarra and Gerard Houllier, which eventually resulted in Houllier publicly saying that he preferred Toulalan. Ouch.
His progress caught the notice of Raymond Domenech, and pretty soon Toulalan began receiving regular call ups to the France NT, and what’s more, he’s been getting regular playing time. He’s pushed Rio Antonio Mavuba, Alou Diarra, Lassana Diarra, and Abou Diaby out of the pecking order and is the mostly likely player to start in Euro 2008 in the event that Makelele retires.

Playing with the big boys.
But though he’s frequently singled out for praise by the press, Toulalan insists his teammates deserve much of the credit for his smooth transition. He says,
“Obviously it’s far easier when you play in a team that is full of quality players. I just focus on my own role, then when I get the ball, it’s a matter of playing a short pass to a team-mate.”
He’s a modest and humble player, and despite his rather physical approach to the game, he’s a shy person who doesn’t talk much. Still, he’s been trying to speak out more often, something that caught Alain Perrin’s eye. Toulalan was even considered for the captaincy when Juninho stepped down. However, Toulalan has gotten the armband on quite a few occasions when Juni and Govou have been substituted, so it’s been doing wonders for his confidence.
So far this season, he’s been one of Lyon’s most consistent players and is part of Lyon’s future. He’s certainly laid to rest the theory that every successful French team needs an African DM. I wouldn’t be surprised to see him be awarded with the captaincy in the next two or three years - should he stay that long. Let’s hope he does.
Watch a rare goal by Toulalan (at the 1:00 min mark).
Interesting facts:
* He’s not a football fan. He readily admits to not following any other teams, even as a boy, though he did have a poster of Romario in his room.
* When he has free time, he likes to take long walks and spend time with his wife Aurelie and his young baby daughter.
* His best friend is PSG goalkeeper Mickael Landreau, his former teammate at Nantes.
* Toulalan has been accused by both Jeremy Berthod and Landreau for being one of the worst dressed players.
* After his Lyon debut (against Nantes, ironically), Toulalan gifted Aulas with his jersey. After his France debut (against the Faroe Islands), Toulalan saved his jersey for his father.
* He’s only 24 but has already started graying around his temples.
Other profiles: Hatem Ben Arfa, Fred, Cris, Kim Kallstrom
Subscribe
|
Print
|
Share
![]() |
Comments
-



He is like Bret Farve, he was a lumberjack with a sensitive side in his past life, and he just decided to take up soccer and was good at it.
Posted from
United States

-



White Makelele? I don’t think so….he has a long way to go for that and dosen’t seem to possess the natural ability and talent that Makelele does. Toulalan is more of a hard working player. I thought Lyon would have been better off with Alou Diarra. Being a Lens fan I saw a lot of him and thought he was the best defensive midfielder in France at the time. Look how well he is doing in Bordeaux now that he is playing again. Sitting on the bench at Lyon was terrible for him. I also see the same for Nadir Belhadj who should be starting somewhere.
Posted from
United States

-



Jay, I disagree. I don’t think Inara said that Toulalan is Makelele now but that he could be as long as he continues progressing and putting in such a great displays. Makelele is a hard working player. He has talent but so does Toulalan. Talent is more than dribbles and tricks. It’s about offering that talent to your team for maximum benefit. For a kid who came from Nantes to being not just a starter for Lyon but also doing well for the National Team, I think that’s a lot of talent right there.
He’s been Lyon’s best player this season even more than Benzema I would wager because Toulalan has been holding up the entire team, not just helping his midfield partenrs but also alleviating the pressure off a weakened defense.
Alou Diarra has a lot of talent and it was wasted on the bench, but with his attitude, it was more than what he deserved. If he was that good he wouldn’t have been dislodged by Toulalan on both the national team and at Lyon. He might have a lot of talent but Lyon don’t need a petulant whiner who doesn’t accept responsibility.
Posted from
United States

-



I also think “White Makelele” doesn’t mean Toulalan is a paler version of Makelele but that Toulalan could be just as important to the setup of the team.
Posted from
United States

-



Toulalan is WAY better than Diarra.
And he doesn’t whine.Toulalan seems highly underrated. When do you see a guy finish a game with a 100% win challenges stat? I’ve only seen it once in my life and no it wasn’t Deschamps, Makelele or Diarra (lol). It was Toulalan.
He’s a monster, and you can’t realize how good he is unless you focus on him for one game.
Makelele is grossly overrated. He’s extremely good when it comes to positionning, tacical approach and ref intimidation.
However, he can’t pass or shoot to save his life, and is physically frail (though he plays bigger than he is).
Toulalan is a tough customer physically, is very aware tactically (though not at Makelele’s level yet), is extremely intelligent on the field (very good positionning too) and he makes very nice passes.Toulalan brings much more than Makelele football-wise right now, the difference is obviously that Makelele is much more experienced. And a known cheater too, which can be helpful (and I hate to say it).
Toulalan is ALL about the natural ability.
Posted from
United States

-



Definately agree that Toualan is a greater talent than Diarra.
Its strange when he first arrived at Lyon he really bugged me with his amazing ability to collect yellow cards and threaten to bring the team down to ten men. Then I started to see just how strong and how intelligent his play is. In many ways he seems so discrete and yet he gets everywhere, makes such a difference. I agree with Evilo that when you focus just on him for a while you realise just how strong his contribution is.
He also seems (almost uniquely in the team) to be able to rise above the crisis of nerves and confidence that hits the team from time to time. When everyone else was wobbling under the growing injury/bad results a few weeks back, Toulalan seemed to be able to hold his head and go from strength to strength. It just didn’t seem to effect his play at all. With a team as apparently sensitive as Lyon its great to have at least one player like that!
Irana there was an interview a few weeks back when Perrin was pondering who to make captain and he suggested that Toulalan might be good but that he lacked charisma. I was really suprised, that sounds so insulting and a strange thing to say in public. Perrin doesn’t exactly seem like Mr Charisma himself!Posted from
France

-



I remember reading that. Perrin wasn’t flattering anyone in that interview - he also said he didn’t like goalkeeper captains and that Govou would be a good choice if only he could play more intelligently (!).
I think what he meant when he said Jeremy wasn’t charismatic was that he’s not expressive enough yet. While he has been making progress in the department of speaking out and arguing with the refs, he’s still unsure of his own position among his teammates and is more likely to hang back then lead the crowd. But I think that will change though. Last season he hardly talked to anyone besides Squillaci and Clerc, and this season he’s seen with almost everybody.
Posted from
United States

-



I’m used to call him “Le Pitbull”, when I watch OL games.
He’s so impressive on the ball, always tackling just like a dog who wanna bite to keep the ball. I love that kind of scottish spirit, never surrender. I’ll call him “Pure Malt”, at the Gerland tomorrow !Posted from
France

-



(And everybody - here in Lyon - say that he has 3 lungs. He never stop running).
Posted from
France

-



Evelio,
Stop smoking funny stuff hombre.
Posted from
United States

-



Toulalan is so positive, which I like. Even after a loss he thinks there are lessons to be learned. This is what he said after the Barca match:
“Perhaps we deserved to lose but I think that this scoreline does not reflect the game adequately. The second-half display from Lyon was much improved from the first 45 minutes and we all felt that we could and should have equalised. However, we didn’t and when Barça’s second goal went in the game was over. There is better to come from us.”
Posted from
United States

-



Don’t get me wrong, I think Toulalan is a fine player but I dont think he is as good, nor will he ever be as good as the legendery Makelele. And I don’t think he is as good as Alou Diarra before Diarra arrived at Lyon. Gerard Houllier ruined that great player and that’s why he was so pissed off. But he is regaining his form for a rising Bordeaux side that could easly challenge Lyon. Also, I don’t think Grosso is anywhere near as good as Belhadj yet Perrin has him benched too. So sad. I wish Belhadj was at Lens….we sure need him. Our roster this year is the pits….
Posted from
United States

-



And I AM smoking some stuff??? Wow!
1- You claim Makelele is legendary. He sure wasn’t legendary when he failed miserably in Marseille. He started being legendary when Jose said so.
2- Alou Diarra a “great” player? Wow, are you sleeping with him or what?
3- Belhadj better than Grosso? Wow again, Grosso was key in the WC, Belhadj had a very good first half last season, but a miserable second half. If ony good half a L1 season makes up for a key play at the WC along with a solid resume, then maybe YOU should quit somking some stuff.
4- BTW, the name is Evilo. I know it’s hard to spell when you’re high, but maybe next time you should avoid posting some stupid stuff all together.
Posted from
United States

-



Evelio,
How old are you kid?
Posted from
United States

-



Evilo… Is it for Olive ?
Calm down, a such great player like you (Olive et Tom ! All my childhood) should not be so restive
Posted from
France

-



i think white makelele is a false argument. the players aren’t similar, two very different but very effective approaches to the same job.
i won’t countenance any dissing of keke, evilo. cela ne se fait pas. he’s a great.
the toulalan story has nothing to do with natural ability… it’s about damned hard work and lots of it. he would have washed out as a youngster at FCNA if not for sheer brutal determination, the same as he displays on the field: 4 lungs is more like it.
he captained france éspoirs and was my choice to succeed juni… one day he’ll captain les bleus and you read it here first.
Posted from
France

-



If any player drives a fan to take drugs, it would be Fred. But anyway, Evilo, Jay, play nice. We’re all entitled to our opinions (I personally think Jose Reina is overrated but that did not score me points at Liverpool fans).
Anyway, as Matthew pointed out, it wasn’t my intention to state that Toulalan is Makelele, as I wouldn’t even say that Nasri is like Zidane (though if you ask the French press, Toulalan is hyped up as Makelele v. 2). But their roles on their respective teams are similar. Makelele is a background player who does the dirty work in the background. Same with Toulalan. Since his season started, he’s been one of the main reasons Lyon have even some fluidity in midfield, but all the praise has been towards Juni, Govou, and Benzema.
Guys like Makelele and Toulalan are the ones who run the team but they never get noticed.
Posted from
United States

-



Jay, I’m 30 and I work in a football school in Normandy. I train 11 to 15 year old kids, and some of them go to pro football.
I also played with Frederic Nee as a youngster, playing in that very school.And I see you still can’t spell my name properly.
And yes Jo, that’s for Olive, nick of Olivier, my first name.
Posted from
United States

-



So Toulalan with another huge game.
And for Jay, look who was responsible for Kallstrom’s goal?
Who intercepts the ball and quickly (and that was the key) passes it to Kallstrom?
Who stopped half of Lens’ attacks?Posted from
United States

-



Evelio,
Whatever kid.
Posted from
United States

-



And you still can’t spell.
How old are you, 78?Posted from
United States

Comments are closed












